Carl McCarthy Lawyer Reviews & Ratings - New York

Donald G. Koch
Reviews
The work itself was ok, but it wasn't worth $425 an hour to work out a payment plan with the IRS. Also, even though you interview with Donald when yo... ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 1.00/5  

Anne D'Elia
Reviews
And compassionate unlike Anne who always yelled and screamed at me.. Funny how I got everything from ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 1.00/5  

Harvey Shapiro
Reviews
My greencard process for EB2 was started by this useless individual because of whom I lost the most valuable 6 years of my greencard wait and had to s... ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 1.43/5  

Kevin J. Hotter
Reviews
Several years ago, Kevin Werner represented me in my divorce. His mistakes, omissions, false assurances, and just plain bad advice cost me several th...a Divorce clientI had the most basic divorce ever - neither one of us wanted money or property or anything, just didn't want to be married anymore. $6K later, and ov...ChristineKevin nor any member of his staff did not return any of my phone calls, e-mails or letters. Extremely dissapointed and wished I would have had a diff...a Child Custody clientHe never returns calls. He will take your $5,000 retainer and send you to his colleagues. I received a $28,000 bill for him doing nothing! Good luck i...a Divorce clientTerrible experience. My messages were ignored by Kevin Werner and his paralegal. Going through a divorce is difficult enough but not getting paperwor...a Divorce clientPoor rating across the board. There's just no other word than inept. After 25 years practicing divorce law there is no excuse for ineptitude on this...a clientDo yourself a favor and hire someone else. If you want to be charged a lot of money without any results or action go for it. You will repeat yoursel...a clientHe walks around with a big ego but is the worst lawyer. He’ll talk a big game to you so you retain him but once he has your money you’re old news. Nev...Maria I was very happy with Mr. Werner and found him to be knowledgable as we ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 1.44/5  

Gary B. Pillersdorf
Reviews
This lawyer I found to be unethical. he in his own words "does not believein truth justice and American way.: he would send young lawyers into court w... ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 1.50/5  

Seth Ian Katz
Reviews
Never informed me about upcoming letter of License suspension. Very poor communication. Rude, abrasive on the phone.... ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 1.80/5  

Ram M. Cheerath
Reviews
He is the best immigration attorney ever .I will recoment this attorney . ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 2.00/5  

Andre R. Sobolevsky
Reviews
Long story short 10 k and 3 years later my case got denied. When I called him he had no interest in speaking with me, he said my case was a flop to be... ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 2.33/5  

Robert M. Preston
Reviews
- His staff sent a hardcopy of my finances to the wrong address and thank God the person that received my package called me. - He was also double bo... ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 2.33/5  

Philip H. Teplen
Reviews
I do not recommend this lawyer. I hired him in 2012 to handle a business transaction. That was before I knew he was disbarred and had discipline taken... ...read more from avvo
Avvo Rating 2.33/5