Internal prototype — noindexed, not linked from public navigation yet.

N.Y. CPL Law § 470.05

This is the official text of N.Y. CPL Law § 470.05, part of New York’s CPL Law — part of the compiled statutory law of New York, published by the state as "CPL Law." Browse the sections below, each linked to its official government source.

Not legal advice. This page reproduces the official text of a government statute for reference only. Laws change, and how a statute applies depends on your specific facts. For advice about your situation, consult a licensed attorney in your state.

Determination of appeals; general criteria

Official statutory text

§ 470.05 Determination of appeals; general criteria.\n 1. An appellate court must determine an appeal without regard to\ntechnical errors or defects which do not affect the substantial rights\nof the parties.\n 2. For purposes of appeal, a question of law with respect to a ruling\nor instruction of a criminal court during a trial or proceeding is\npresented when a protest thereto was registered, by the party claiming\nerror, at the time of such ruling or instruction or at any subsequent\ntime when the court had an opportunity of effectively changing the same.\nSuch protest need not be in the form of an "exception" but is sufficient\nif the party made his position with respect to the ruling or instruction\nknown to the court, or if in reponse to a protest by a party, the court\nexpressly decided the question raised on appeal. In addition, a party\nwho without success has either expressly or impliedly sought or\nrequested a particular ruling or instruction, is deemed to have thereby\nprotested the court's ultimate disposition of the matter or failure to\nrule or instruct accordingly sufficiently to raise a question of law\nwith respect to such disposition or failure regardless of whether any\nactual protest thereto was registered.\n

Status: in_force · Read it on the official government site

Need a lawyer in New York?

Find a New York lawyer
About this page: Statute text is reproduced from official government publishers via the Open US Law dataset (Vaquill AI, snapshot v2026.08, CC BY 4.0). Primary legislative text like this is public domain under the government-edicts doctrine (Georgia v. Public.Resource.Org, 2020). We link every section back to its official source so you can verify it independently.