Top criminal defense Lawyers in Middletown | 3 available

3 criminal defense lawyers are available in Middletown, New York, including Arthur Shapiro, John Ingrassia, and John Scott Bonacic. These lawyers are rated between 3.7/5 to 4.1/5 and 61% provide free consultation.

Arthur Shapiro

John Ingrassia

John Scott Bon

criminal defense Lawyers Nearby Middletown (by distance)

Within 50 miles near you

Cincinnati, Ohio ZIP 45202 30.6 mi away 26 lawyers Newport, Kentucky ZIP 41071 32.9 mi away 12 lawyers Lawrenceburg, Indiana ZIP 47025 35.9 mi away 2 lawyers

View Profile

Avvo Rating:

Arthur Shapiro

Firm: Blustein, Shapiro & Rich, LLP

90 Crystal Run Road 409 New 10941 , Middletown , New York 10941

Practice Areas: Criminal Defense ,Estate Planning,Family ,Real Estate

View Profile

Avvo Rating:

John Ingrassia

Firm: Larkin Ingrassia, PLLC

626 E Main St, Middletown, NY 10940 , Middletown , New York 10940

Practice Areas: Assault & Battery, Criminal Defense , Drug Crimes, DUI/DWI, Felonies, Parole and Probation, Sexual Abuse, Traffic Violations, Criminal Defense

Attorney John Ingrassia, a partner at Larkin Ingrassia Criminal Defense Attorneys, has been a steadfast advocate for clients in Middletown, NY, for decades. With an exclusive focus on criminal defense, he has become a trusted name in the local legal community, representing individuals facing a broad spectrum of charges. Whether navigating a complex felony case or a misdemeanor, Attorney Ingrassia delivers personalized, results-driven representation to clients throughout Middletown and the greater Hudson Valley.. A significant portion of Attorney Ingrassia’s Middletown practice is dedicated to defending clients charged with Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) offenses. From trials and suppression hearings to appeals and DMV administrative proceedings, he has a proven track record of achieving favorable outcomes for individuals accused of operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs. His deep knowledge of New York’s DWI laws, combined with his extensive trial experience, makes him a sought-after defender in Middletown.. Beyond DWI cases, Attorney Ingrassia is a well-known domestic violence lawyer in Middletown, NY. He handles an extensive range of criminal matters, including assault, drug offenses, sex crimes, theft, and white-collar crimes. He has also successfully defended high-profile cases and secured acquittals on charges such as manslaughter, attempted murder, and official misconduct. His ability to navigate the complexities of criminal law and his dedication to protecting his clients’ rights have earned him respect among clients and colleagues alike.. Attorney Ingrassia’s roots in the Hudson Valley legal community run deep. A former Orange County Assistant District Attorney, he has also served in leadership roles with the Orange County Bar Association and remains active in professional organizations. For clients in Middletown, NY, Attorney Ingrassia offers the seasoned experience and unwavering advocacy needed to confront criminal charges and protect their futures.

Avvo Review

“and more. His knowledge of the law is second to none. He anticipated every move, countered every c”

Read on Avvo

Lawyers.com Review

“I endorse this lawyer.”

Google Review

“I don't know who is leaving fake Google reviews go to Yelp and you will see different reviews. I've paid this firm 10k dollars and I can't get anyone to call me back after 11 weeks…”

— Jean Lari

View Profile

Avvo Rating:

John Scott Bonacic

Firm: Bonacic, Krahulik and Associates, LLP

90 Crystal Run Road 104 New 10941 , Middletown , New York 10941

Practice Areas: Corporate ,Criminal Defense ,Real Estate

Google Review

“I just received my original deed in the mail from Scott's paralegal and it reminded me that I forgot to write a review after my move. This is the second time that I have used Scott…”

— Kathryn Loughran

Describe Your Case — We'll Connect You With a Matching Lawyer

Save This Search

Recent Q&As in New York (criminal defense)

Lawyer Communication | Aug 12, 2026 | Sourced from Reddit
Location: New York. Hello everyone, I have an ongoing criminal case currently and recently it has been another court date for me. I’m a college student and will be going back to school very soon, my next court date is during my school time. At my most recent court date, I asked my public defender if I’ll have to be there with them next time. They said if there is any difficulty with time to contact them, I told them that in earlier times when I tried to contact them through phone calls I didn’t receive any response, then they told me to contact them through texting. As soon as I checked on my schedule, I texted them in terms of messaging the phone number they left on their card that I wouldn’t be able to attend my next court date due to school reasons. It has been a day or two, and I haven’t gotten any responses back yet. They left two numbers, one for office and one for cell, in case, I messaged both. The message to the cell is colored blue and tells me that my message is delivered but not read yet. The office message is shown as green and doesn’t show whether or not it’s read or not. Is there anything I should do as of now or anything I could do? My next court date is approximately half a month from now.
First-time NYC subway fare incident resulted in a DAT for Transit Theft of Services — Do I need a private lawyer? | Jul 27, 2026 | Sourced from Reddit
I am an Asian international student living and studying in New York City, and I have never been to criminal court before. I am trying to understand what I should do next. A few days ago, I was stopped by an NYPD officer after entering the subway without successfully paying the fare. My Apple Pay transit payment was not working properly that day, and I also did not have my wallet or physical ID with me. I ended up entering behind my friend. My friend had successfully paid and has a payment record, but I did not. I was fully cooperative with the officer. I did not run, resist, or argue. I eventually showed her a photo of my ID on my phone, and she verified my information. The officer asked whether I had received a ticket before. I told her honestly that I had one prior public consumption of alcohol ticket from 2023. It was a $25 fine for drinking beer in a public park, which I paid online immediately. That is my only prior legal violation. The officer then issued me a Desk Appearance Ticket (DAT) for Transit Theft of Services and told me that I need to appear in Criminal Court. I was very surprised because I had never been to court before. I initially thought this was simply a fare-related fine. The officer told me that the judge would decide the amount of the fine and that it could potentially be as little as $25, with…
Ex assaulted me and the police and DA’s office messed up | Jul 24, 2026 | Sourced from Reddit
Location: New York Hey everyone, I really need some advice on this if you can help me. Earlier this year, I was viciously assaulted by my ex, where he had cut up my arm, and I called the police and filed an order of protection against him, which was granted. When the police came over, they took photographs of my injured arm, and they called the ambulance to treat me. I declined going to the hospital because I did not think that I needed to because I wasn’t sure what they could even do with these cuts because they were pretty deep but I figured they probably did not require stitches so I did not go to the hospital. Because I did not go to the hospital and get a doctors note, New York State literally charged my ex with attempted assault in the third- degree rather than actual assault – the police officer told me today that because I did not go to the hospital to get my injuries checked out, I can’t do anything about this and I can’t have him charged with assault. Furthermore, the ADA that was working on my case notified me about two days after his arrest, and never informed me that she could not press charges for assault because I had not gone to the damned ER, and instead had charges filed for attempted assault in the third degree; one of the glaring differences with these two charges is that assault is a…

See more Q&A Ask a Lawyer (free)

New York Statutes — Criminal Defense

Penal Law: defines crimes and punishments in New York.

Browse the full New York Penal Law →

Official government statute text, reproduced for reference — not legal advice. For your situation, consult a licensed attorney.

You have reached the Last Page!

Disclaimer: This content is based on aggregated public information and estimated market trends. It is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.