Scott K. McCarthy - Madison Personal Injury Lawyer Reviews & Ratings
Scott K. McCarthy has an average rating of 4.2/5 based on 42 reviews and practices at Murphy Desmond S.C. in Madison, Wisconsin. Practice areas include Appellate, Civil, Criminal Defense, Debtor/Creditor Rights, Personal Injury law.
Scott K. McCarthy
Is this your profile?
Claim it and unlock:
- ✓ Verified badge on your profile
- ✓ Full control to edit your name, phone, address, bio, and photo
- ✓ Priority when we match new client leads
- ✓ Verified badge on your Q&A answers
- ✓ No search ads shown on your profile
About Scott K. McCarthy
Scott K. McCarthy has a rating of 5.0/5 based on 1 client reviews. Scott K. McCarthy is a Appellate attorney based in Madison, Wisconsin. The attorney practices with Murphy Desmond S.C.. Services are available throughout Dane County.
Office Location
Scott K. McCarthy is located at Manchester Place, Madison, Wisconsin 53701.
Legal Services in Madison, Wisconsin
Residents seeking legal representation in Madison often compare experience, client reviews, practice areas, and location before selecting an attorney. This profile provides information about Scott K. McCarthy, including available ratings, reviews, practice areas, and service locations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What practice areas does Scott K. McCarthy handle?
Scott K. McCarthy handles Appellate, Civil, Criminal Defense, Debtor/Creditor Rights, Personal Injury matters in Madison and nearby areas.
What is the attorney rating?
Available review information indicates a rating of 5.0/5 based on 1 client reviews.
How can I contact Scott K. McCarthy?
Call 608-314-3800 for information regarding consultations and legal services.
Questions Scott K. McCarthy Could Answer
-
Personal injury options Jul 28, 2026personal injury attorney — WisconsinI got injured a couple months ago and I need advice on next steps. Location: Wisconsin. Basically I was on a guided tour. There weren’t real good step railings and I slipped. I was helped up quickly by staff almost too quickly and I ended up fainting. I got some…
-
Wi misdemeanor charges Jul 24, 2026criminal defense attorney — WisconsinHopefully I can ask this - location: in SE Wisconsin. My boyfriend got himself into some trouble this past weekend after golf. He was pulled over for speeding while passing someone who sped up as he was trying to pass, 74 mph in a 55. He had just finished a…
Average Rating: 4.2
Total Reviews 42
Total Reviews 42
Google Rating:
4.2 (41 reviews)
Avvo Review
“Scott is intimidating and a boss in the court room. He helped me get everything I wanted in my divorce. I have recommended him to everyone I know.”Read on Avvo
Google Review
“Maggie is absolutely fantastic! I reached out to her for a second opinion, as I felt my current attorney was not supporting me properly. Maggie gave me more feedback, guidance, answers, time, and confidence in an hour long consultation than …”— Danielle Schumacher (5/5)
Google Review
“I cannot recommend Scott McCarthy highly enough! As an Illinois driver dealing with a case in Wisconsin, I was completely overwhelmed—especially after receiving bad advice from a previous attorney that left me with a plea deal that could …”— Gina Sapienza (5/5)
Google Review
“Scott and his firm were thorough, attentive and prompt with communication. Scott walked me through the legal process and made sure my questions were answered. I would highly recommend using his services.”— G I (5/5)
Murphy Desmond S.C.
Practice Area(s)
Appellate
Civil
Criminal Defense
Debtor/Creditor Rights
Personal Injury
Address
Manchester Place,
Madison
,
53701
Counties Served
Dane County
Are you Scott K. McCarthy's Client ? Submit a review
Describe Your Case to Scott K. McCarthy
Save Lawyer to Mylawbamba
Quick Summary Information for lawyer Scott K. McCarthy on Lawbamba
Scott K. McCarthy has received a total of 42 Lawbamba, Avvo, Yelp, Google and Lawyers.com reviews.
- Free or Complimentary consultation may be available for a few hours.
- Madison Lawyers Fees is generally in the range of $287-$483 per hour.
Compare Scott K. McCarthy's reviews with other lawyers in zip 53701
Appellate Attorney Madison (6 lawyers)
Civil Attorney Madison (14 lawyers)
Personal Injury Attorney Madison (5 lawyers)
- Free or Complimentary consultation may be available for a few hours.
- Madison Lawyers Fees is generally in the range of $287-$483 per hour.
Compare Scott K. McCarthy's reviews with other lawyers in zip 53701
Appellate Attorney Madison (6 lawyers)
Civil Attorney Madison (14 lawyers)
Personal Injury Attorney Madison (5 lawyers)
Here are a few tips to break the ice once you have chosen Scott K. McCarthy
- How many years have you been in practice?- How many Appellate similar cases like mine have you handled?
- How often do you settle Appellate cases out of court?
- What is your fees and the estimated cost of my specific case?
- Does lawyer Scott K. McCarthy offer any Pro bono services?
- What are my next steps to proceed?
Disclaimer: Lawbamba is a neutral attorney review platform that displays publicly available ratings and reviews from sources including Lawbamba Community reviews, Avvo, Yelp, Lawyers.com, and Google. Users may also submit reviews about their experience with Scott K. McCarthy. Verified community reviews may be published in the Lawbamba Community Reviews section.
Scott K. McCarthy serves 53701 . Switch Zip?
Compare Personal Injury Lawyer reviews and ratings in nearby cities to Wisconsin with similar ratings to Scott K. McCarthy
Listed below are the Local Lawyers in Wisconsin who are rated close to Scott K. McCarthy . Compare the reviews and select the right Lawyer for your needs.
Frederick Melms
Fred took over a complicated and chaotic family law case for me during one of the lowest points in my life. He advises from a neutral, honest and fair perspective and leads his client to a just outcome. …
...read more
John R. Orton
It is frustrating when an attorney's website makes it appear as though they are willing to help, but then you're turned away without explanation . . . this after losing a few, precious, pre-hearing days to phone tag. …
...read more
Sydne French
Do not hire Sydne French if you care about your or your loved one’s future. Extremely unprofessional. Calls/emails left unanswered for literally weeks at a time. We didn’t know if she was still representing us at one…
...read more
Gimbel Reilly Guerin & Brown LLP
KUDOS to BRITT ( wearing double hats for marketing & intake advisor)! I cannot speak highly enough about the positive interaction I experienced whilst speaking on the phone with this professional yet oh so personable (se…
...read more
John Sesini
We hired Sisini Law and Tony helped us with my husband’s residency about 4 years ago and they truly did an amazing job, made it easy and fast. Their communication was not the best but they would give me updates so we d…
...read more
Robert J. Kasieta
Bob and Adam were both incredible and basically saved us from the fallout of getting tangled up with a predatory lender. Bobs compassion, professionalism, generosity of his spirit and his time, plus Bob's experience and …
...read more
Brian G. Weber
Got me through one of the toughest times in my life. Knowledgeable, and professional. I would highly recommend.
...read more
Gary L. Wickert
I have been using and referring clients to Matthiesen, Wickert and Lehrer for over 15yrs. Before that, the company I work for has been using their services for another 10. We have had nothing but great experiences, incl…
...read more
Andrew Arena
Andrew is a very thorough and knowledgeable gentleman who helped resolve a complicated traffic citat
...read more
Linda Meagher
Linda is an incredible attorney. She makes you feel like your part of family exceptional professional . She’ll fight to take care of her client!
...read more
John Casey
From the secretaries, to attorney Casey himself.I was treated with compassion and fairness, they were strong where I wasn't, everything went smoothly and I would recommend him to anyone or myself again. The experience wa…
...read more
Jeffrey M. Blessinger
I required a good lawyer for my divorce which had some unusual aspects and gave rise to a conflict of interest for the first lawyer I employed. This r...
...read more
Emily B. DiUlio
I have no idea who these are other reviewers are talking about. Emily has an extremely passive approach towards custody placement disagreements. She...JonAttorney Emily Wilson is a real professional attorney. She is ve…
...read more
Scherr & Scherr
Extremely knowledgeable, trustworthy and truly provided outstanding advice for me. Erich is extremely approachable, easy to get a hold of, and was very honest and straightforward about my car accident case and what the o…
...read more
Zachary Kluck
Bsolutely recommend him to others that are feeling overwhelmed and find themselves needing a bankrup
...read more
Gregg Bridge
Our family had a very difficult experience working with Attorney Greg Bridge. Throughout the process involving my late aunt and family property, it often felt like he was representing only one side of the situation rathe…
...read more
John Marchan
JP is an accomplished and very efficient criminal defense attorney. I would trust JP with any case in criminal court and would recommend JP to anyone interested in a serious defense attorney. He knows the space well as…
...read more
Georgia Konstantakis
I received a traffic citation in December 2025, If the citation was paid I would loose a total of four (4 ) points from my driver's license. This affected my driving career so much causing me to loose my job. I google o…
...read more