Landlord micromanaging our patio—right to privacy issue?
landlord tenant attorney Pennsylvania Nov 6, 2026
Location: Pennsylvania My landlord, in short, is awful. We have had issues in the past where we had mice, they hired an exterminator who only set up baits, and then refused to do more as the home became uninhabitable claiming it must be our fault for having food out. All of our food at that point was being stored in Rubbermaid containers, and when we pointed out that we have restaurants on both sides of us and four dumpsters out back, they ignored us. We had to borrow a cat in order to return to sanitary conditions. Recently, we’ve been in contact with them because the business downstairs will take in our packages (it’s a front and back door situation so misdeliveries happen), keep them for several days, refuse to respond to texts or knocks at their front door to receive the package, and will then return the items from the package after having opened it. This recently happened with medication. The landlord emailed them twice, refused any further action and has now told us to go to the police despite us being clear about the fact that we hear the having violent arguments and do not feel safe. I’m giving this backstory to say that we lived here for 10 years with no issues and have only had issues in the last 2. Since then, the landlord has increasingly pushed our privacy. They show up unannounced and claim “reasonable notice” is when they text us from outside the door before immediately unlocking it. And each time we have spoken with them about the downstairs neighbors, they send someone to come look at our back patio and find things for us to do or fix. Today, they messaged us about some empty packaging on the patio. I informed them that when the garbage company empties the cardboard recycling, often times debris falls out and gets caught in our fenced in patio. I try to keep up as best I can but it happens. I put the offending cardboard back in the dumpster and sent them picture to show it was gone. So far, this is annoying but fairly reasonable. They respond with additional requests including calling our patio rug trash and instructing us to throw it out, moving a watering can off a patio chair, and rearranging our flower pots to be more aesthetically pleasing in the off season here. To me, this is too far for a landlord to go—it felt like they came into our home and asked us to rearrange the furniture. The patio belongs to our apartment, though the business can use the (always unobstructed) back door as an emergency exit. Before I started the garden it was literally full of trash and debris and never maintained (this was for about 6 years). It is also in the back of the property so the argument of it being some kind of eyesore for the business does not apply. We also pointed out to her that we’ve mentioned the corner of the patio is literally crumbling and the foundation (it’s raised high above a lowered parking lot) has been buckling outwards for years and nothing has been done for those issues, yet the flower pots in November are a problem. Does that type of request violate our tenants right to privacy? The increasing scrutiny feels targeted due to our challenges getting them to act, and I honestly at my wits end (and actively looking for a new place to live).